How to Quote Custom Manufacturing Jobs Accurately (Without Margin Mistakes)

By Robert Hargrove, Founder · · 9 min read

The short answer

Capture your costs as accurately as you can, whether they're estimated from previous projects or taken from a bill of materials (BOM), then set the price from the margin you need rather than a simple markup. Check the result at each quantity break and in the currency you'll be paid in, and keep a record of how you priced it.

Quoting custom products and projects is tricky. You might be modifying an existing product or sub-assembly, adding design work, or building from a customer's drawing. Early quotes are often made before any drawing exists: you estimate the cost impact of the changes (different connectors, a larger chassis, extra testing) from previous projects, and only create formal drawings once the customer is moving forward.

I spent more than ten years in technical sales, mostly in power electronics, quoting everything from catalog units to one-off builds. Most of what follows I learned from experience, including sometimes getting it wrong.

Why custom quoting is different

A distributor quotes from a price list. Someone already decided what the product costs and what it sells for, and the salesperson applies a discount. A custom shop doesn't have that luxury. Every new request is a small engineering problem: what is it made of, how long does it take to build, and what does the customer actually need?

A single quote rarely contains just one kind of line. It might include a catalog product, a modified version of one, engineering time, and a one-off build made to the customer's drawing. Each is priced differently, and some of them may not have a drawing yet.

What an inaccurate quote really costs

Quote too high and you lose the job. Quote too low and you win it, then the margin disappears once the job is built. Other costs are quieter: the wrong revision means rework or scrap, forgotten setup time makes small orders lose money, and an early estimate that was never recorded becomes impossible to explain or improve later.

Step 1: Decide whether this is an early estimate or a firm quote

Not every quote starts with a finished drawing.

An early quote can simply say that it's budgetary. A firm quote should name the revision.

Step 2: Capture the costs, estimated or from a BOM

For a firm quote, the bill of materials lists everything that goes into the part, with a quantity and a unit cost for each line. A usable BOM includes purchased parts and raw materials, current unit costs, sub-assemblies, and consumables. If engineering gives you a BOM exported from CAD, import it rather than retyping it. Most quoting errors are transcription mistakes: a quantity of 4 typed as 40, or a part pulled from the wrong row.

For an early estimate, apply known adders or comparable costs from previous jobs, and keep a record of which ones you used.

Either way, check any cost older than about three months, and check volatile materials (copper, steel, semiconductors) every time.

For more on costing the BOM itself, see BOM Costing Best Practices for Custom Manufacturers.

Step 3: Cost the labour, including the hours nobody sees

Labour is where custom quotes usually go wrong. Break it into the operations it really takes:

Hourly rates should already carry your overhead. Setup is the one to watch: two hours at $110 is $220. On one unit that's $220 extra; on ten units it's $22 each. Ignoring setup makes large orders look fine and small orders lose money.

Many shops also price first-article or prototype builds differently from production quantities. Make that difference clear in the numbers.

Step 4: Turn cost into price with margin, not markup

Margin is a percentage of the selling price. Markup is a percentage of cost. Mixing them up is the most common margin mistake.

Let's work through an example: a small control enclosure.

Cost lineDetailCost (CAD)
MaterialsFrom the BOM$412.60
Assembly and wiring4.5 h at $75$337.50
Machine time1.2 h at $110$132.00
Total cost per unit$882.10

The difference is $166.24 per unit. On 20 units that's more than $3,300. If you price with a cost multiplier, know what margin it gives: a multiplier of 3 is a 66.7 percent margin, and a multiplier of 1.5 is 33.3 percent.

Step 5: Check every quantity break and the currency

Customers usually ask for several quantities. Price each break on its own, since setup is spread over more units and parts often get cheaper at volume, then check the margin at every break. A discount at 50 units can push the margin lower than you would accept.

Note the exchange rate you used and give the quote a clear validity period, so a move in the currency or in commodity prices doesn't come out of your margin later.

Step 6: Write a clear quote

A quote needs to be unambiguous. At a minimum include:

Engineering services should appear as their own lines. Customer-supplied parts should be listed as “customer supplied” at zero cost.

Before the quote goes out, a quick internal review of the labour and setup numbers is worthwhile, especially on first builds.

Step 7: Keep a record of how you priced it

Save the costed BOM or the list of adders you used, the rates, the margin, and a short internal note on where the numbers came from. The next time the customer asks, you want to see what you charged and why, not just a number in an old email.

Step 8: Hand off the won quote without retyping it

When the customer says yes, the quote should become the order without the information being typed again. When an early estimate turns into a real project, convert it into a proper BOM-based quote once the drawing exists, and keep both versions.

Common margin mistakes and how to prevent them

Spreadsheets or a quoting system?

A spreadsheet is fine when one person quotes a handful of jobs and knows where everything lives. It gets harder when several people quote, when parts are re-quoted often, or when an early estimate has to become a firm quote, then an order, then an invoice.

A structured system keeps the BOM (or the list of estimated adders), labour, margin, currency, and revision status together on the quote, and keeps the history. Tools built for custom manufacturers, like the Modustra IQ Margin Calculator, can import a BOM, cost it with parts and labour, and show the price and margin at every quantity break.

Checklist: what a good custom quote includes

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to quote custom manufacturing jobs?
Decide whether this is an early estimate or a firm quote. For early quotes, estimate cost impacts from previous projects and keep a record of the adders you used. For firm quotes, start from the named revision, build a bill of materials, and cost every part and hour of labour, including setup. In both cases, set the price from the margin you need and check each quantity break.
How do you calculate margin on a BOM?
Add the material and labour costs to get the total cost per unit, then divide by one minus the margin. For example, $882.10 at a 35 percent margin is $882.10 ÷ 0.65 = $1,357.08.
What's the difference between margin and markup?
Markup is a percentage of cost; margin is a percentage of the selling price. A 35 percent markup produces only a 25.9 percent margin.
Why do custom quotes lose money?
Most often because markup is used instead of margin, setup is left out of small orders, costs or adders are out of date, the wrong revision is quoted, or a discount at a higher quantity quietly drops the margin.
How should customer-supplied parts be handled?
List them on the quote as “customer supplied” at zero cost, so it's clear they're part of the build but not part of the price.
How do you handle quotes before a drawing exists?
Treat them as budgetary estimates. Use adders from previous projects, keep an internal record of what you used, and convert to a proper BOM-based quote once a drawing is created and the customer moves forward.

This is a simple walk-through of a process every shop runs a little differently. Your rates, margins, and terms will be your own.

More from Shop Talk, or see the Margin Calculator and plans and pricing.

Not ready to register?

Leave your email for product updates, or to ask about complimentary Pro for early partners.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe any time.