BOM Costing Best Practices for Custom Manufacturers (and the Costs a BOM Usually Misses)

By Robert Hargrove, Founder · · 12 min read

The short answer

Cost every line of the bill of materials (BOM) at what it will really cost to buy for this job: the landed cost, at the quantity you will actually order, in the unit you actually use, with an allowance for scrap. Add the lines a CAD export leaves out, including direct labour and machine hours, keep pure overhead out, and record where each cost came from and when.

In How to Quote Custom Manufacturing Jobs Accurately, the materials for the worked example were a single line: “Materials, from the BOM, $412.60.” This article is mostly about that one line, and about what else belongs on the BOM beside it. A costed BOM looks exact, with a price beside every part and a total at the bottom, and that is what makes it easy to trust more than it deserves.

Most material cost errors are not arithmetic errors. The spreadsheet adds up correctly. The problem is what each number means: a catalogue price with no freight, a 100-piece price on a 20-piece buy, a US dollar cost in a Canadian dollar column, or a line that was never there at all.

What a costed BOM is

An engineering BOM says what the product is made of. A costed BOM says what it costs you to make. Each line needs a part number and description, a quantity per unit, a unit of measure, a unit cost, and an extended cost (quantity times unit cost). Labour is a line like any other: the quantity is hours and the unit cost is the hourly rate. The extended costs add up to the direct cost of one unit.

Two more columns are worth the effort: where the cost came from (a supplier quote, the last purchase, a catalogue, or an estimate) and the date. Without them, nobody can tell a firm number from a guess six months later.

Start from the engineering BOM, then add what it leaves out

If engineering can export a BOM from CAD, import it. Then go looking for what CAD does not model. In most shops that list is about the same every time:

Small items do not each need their own line. A single “consumables kit” line with a realistic cost is far better than nothing. What matters is that the cost is on the BOM, not left for the margin to absorb.

Cost in the unit you use, not the unit you buy

We buy wire by the spool, bar by the length, and sheet by the sheet. We use it by the metre and by the piece. Every line needs its cost converted to the unit in the quantity column.

Hookup wire at $185.00 for a 150 m spool is $1.23 a metre. A unit that uses 12 m carries $14.80 of wire. Entering the spool price against a quantity of 12, or the per-metre price against a quantity of 1, are both easy mistakes to make and hard ones to spot.

Use landed cost, not the catalogue price

Landed cost is what a part costs by the time it is on your shelf: the price, converted to your currency, plus freight, brokerage, and any duty. The catalogue price is only the first of those.

Take a power supply at US$42.00. At an exchange rate of 1.38 that is $57.96 Canadian. If freight and brokerage on a shipment of ten come to $26.00, that adds $2.60 each, for a landed cost of $60.56. Entering “42.00” in a Canadian dollar column understates the line by $18.56, about 31 percent.

You do not need this precision on every resistor. You do need it on the expensive imported lines, which are usually the ones that decide the total.

Cost at the quantity you will actually buy

Supplier pricing comes in breaks, and the attractive number at the bottom of the table is for a quantity you may not be buying. A connector at $4.10 in hundreds might be $6.85 in tens. If the job needs 20, the cost is $6.85.

Minimum order quantities (the smallest amount a supplier will sell) work the same way, only harder. A custom gasket with a minimum of 500 pieces at $0.40 is a $200.00 purchase. If the job needs 40 and you have no other use for the rest, the gasket costs this job $5.00 each, not $0.40. If you will use the remainder on other work, cost it at $0.40. Either way, make it a decision and not an accident.

Setup and lot charges from outside suppliers belong here too. An engraver who charges $50.00 for setup plus $3.50 a piece is charging $8.50 a piece on an order of ten.

Allow for scrap and yield on the line

Material that is bought but does not end up in the product still has to be paid for: the offcut of the bar, the skeleton of the sheet, the wire trimmed at each termination, the small parts that are dropped or damaged.

Sheet is the classic case. A back panel might use 14 percent of a $96.00 sheet by area, which is $13.44. If only six panels nest on a sheet, each one really costs $16.00.

Put the allowance on the line it belongs to, as a quantity or a cost, where the next person can see it. A hidden percentage added to the total gets forgotten, or gets added twice.

Cost sub-assemblies once and roll them up

If a wiring harness or a machined bracket is used in several products, give it its own BOM and its own cost. The parent BOM then carries one line: the sub-assembly, its quantity, and its rolled-up cost.

The alternative is copying the harness lines into every product that uses it. The copies start out identical and then drift, because a price gets updated in one and not the others. One sub-assembly costed once is easier to keep right.

Use replacement cost, and write down where it came from

For a quote, the cost that matters is what you will pay to buy the part for this job (replacement cost). Stock on the shelf from two years ago is tempting to cost at what you paid for it, but once it is used it has to be replaced at today's price.

Not every line deserves a fresh supplier quote. Sort the BOM by extended cost. The few lines at the top carry most of the money and are worth a phone call. The long tail at the bottom can run on the last purchase price without much risk. Mark any line that is an estimate as an estimate, so it gets firmed up before the order is placed.

Put direct labour on the BOM, and keep pure overhead off it

The hours that go directly into making the product belong on the BOM: direct manufacturing labour, and machine hours where the job needs them. They are as much a part of what the unit costs as the parts are, and a BOM without them only tells half the story.

Pure overhead does not belong there. Admin labour, electricity, and insurance are real costs, but they are not costs of this unit, and there is no honest quantity to put beside them. They are recovered through the hourly rates on the labour and machine lines, so every hour you quote carries its share. Adding them again as BOM lines counts them twice.

A worked example: what sits behind a materials number

Here is the costed BOM for the small control enclosure from the quoting article, per unit for an order of ten: the twelve lines behind the $412.60 of materials, then the labour and machine hours.

LineQuantity and cost basisCost (CAD)
Enclosure, powder coated1 at $118.00, supplier quote$118.00
Back panelSix per $96.00 sheet$16.00
Power supply1 at US$42.00, landed$60.56
Circuit breakers3 at $14.20$42.60
Terminal blocks24 at $1.85$44.40
Pilot lights and switches4 at $11.50$46.00
Connectors2 at $6.85, the 10-piece price$13.70
Filter fan kit1 at $17.54$17.54
Hookup wire12 m at $1.23 a metre$14.80
Engraved nameplate$50.00 setup plus $3.50 each, on ten$8.50
Consumables kitDIN rail, duct, hardware, labels, ferrules$21.00
PackagingCarton and foam$9.50
Materials subtotal$412.60
Assembly and wiring4.5 h at $75.00$337.50
Machine time1.2 h at $110.00$132.00
Total cost per unit$882.10

Now cost the materials the quick way: the CAD export, with a catalogue price beside each line.

LineWhat the quick version didMissed (CAD)
Power supplyUS$42.00 entered as Canadian, no freight$18.56
Back panelCosted by area, not by the nest$2.56
Connectors100-piece price on a 20-piece buy$5.50
Engraved nameplatePiece price without the setup charge$5.00
Consumables kitNot on the CAD BOM$21.00
PackagingNot on the CAD BOM$9.50
Total missed per unit$62.12

The quick version puts the materials at $350.48, about 15 percent low, and no single line looks wrong. The labour lines are the same, so the total comes to $819.98 where it should be $882.10. A 35 percent margin on the understated cost gives a price of $1,261.51 where it should have been $1,357.08. The real margin on that quote is 30.1 percent. That is $95.57 a unit, or $955.70 on the order of ten, lost before the job starts.

Tie the costed BOM to a revision

A costed BOM belongs to one revision of the drawing. When the design changes, cost the new revision and keep the old one, so you can see what changed and what it did to the cost. A BOM that is quietly edited in place cannot explain last year's quote.

Common BOM costing mistakes

Where software helps

Everything above can be done in a spreadsheet, and many shops do it well that way. It gets harder as the number of parts grows, as sub-assemblies are shared between products, and as more than one person updates costs.

Tools built for custom manufacturers keep the parts, their costs, and the BOMs that use them in one place. In Modustra IQ, the Margin Calculator imports a BOM from a spreadsheet, costs it from catalog parts plus manual lines for machine time and assembly labour, refreshes the costs when prices change, and records every save. The BOM Explorer in Production shows what every catalog part is made of, sub-assemblies included, with its material cost.

The Modustra IQ BOM Explorer: a search box, filters for standard and custom parts and for parts with or without a bill of materials, and a list of catalog parts with part number, revision, description, a Custom badge where it applies, and material cost.
The BOM Explorer: every catalog part, standard or custom, with its revision and material cost.

Checklist: a costed BOM you can trust

Frequently asked questions

What is a costed BOM?
A bill of materials where every line has a quantity, a unit cost, and an extended cost, so the lines add up to the direct cost of one unit: materials, bought-in services, direct labour, and machine hours. A good one also records where each cost came from and when.
What costs does a BOM usually miss?
Direct labour and machine hours, when the BOM starts as a CAD export; freight, duty, and exchange on imported parts; consumables such as wire, hardware, and labels; outside processes and their setup or lot charges; packaging; and scrap.
Should labour and overhead be included in a BOM?
Direct manufacturing labour and machine hours, yes: they go on the BOM as lines, with hours and a rate. Pure overhead such as admin labour, electricity, and insurance, no. It is recovered through the hourly rates, and adding it as BOM lines counts it twice.
Should I cost parts at what I last paid or at today's price?
For a quote, use replacement cost: what it will cost to buy the part for this job. Stock bought cheaply two years ago still has to be replaced at today's price.
How do you handle minimum order quantities?
Cost the line at the quantity you will actually buy. If the minimum is larger than the job needs and you have no other use for the rest, the whole minimum buy is a cost of the job.
How do you cost a BOM with sub-assemblies?
Give each sub-assembly its own BOM, cost it once, and let its total roll up into the parent as a single line. Copying the lines into each parent creates two versions that drift apart.

None of this is complicated, and every shop will draw the lines a little differently. The numbers in the example are made up to show the method. Yours will be your own.

More from Shop Talk, or see the Margin Calculator and plans and pricing.

Not ready to register?

Leave your email for product updates, or to ask about complimentary Pro for early partners.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe any time.